Thursday, June 7, 2012

"War Hero"

There have been suspicions that this "war hero" was never actually injured in Afghanistan. Do you believe his story or do you think he made up a "sob story" to increase his likeability with America? Does he deserve to move on to the next level of America's Got Talent or do you think his singing wasn't good enough?

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

I would like to think he wouldn't lie about that. Hes really scummy if he did. He also doesn't deserve to go on in the competition. His singing was actually pretty decent. So if he didn't lie and doesn't lose his voice I think he might go farther.
Kyle E.

Anonymous said...

I'm really surprised that he wasn't injured bad in Afghanistan. Yes I do believe his story. Yes he deserve to move on to the next level of America's Got Talent. He's really good. That's all I can say.
Jaquitta

Drewskee said...

I would hope that he didn't make it up but I believe him because I don't think anybody would lie about that stuff. I think he should definitely go to the next round his singing did sound pretty good.

Emily Walker said...

I heard on the radio that it was all a lie because they never had record of that happening. I believe that it's a that he made up the sob story to increase his likability. I don't believe that he should make it to the next round because it should be based on the talent not the story, especially if the story is fake.

Kiran said...

For some reason I really don't think this is fake. There could have been a mistake. When he was hit with the grenade, no one probably recorded it. I don't think this is a sob story. I actually think his singing was good. Even if he hadn't told his reason why he stuttered, he still sounded good so I think he should move on.

Tabitha said...

I watch American Got Talent a lot. When I saw this man I got the chills through my body. It’s truly inspiring and he is a wonderful singer. I hope he goes far in the competition. I can’t believe that when he sings he doesn’t stutter that’s awesome! I don’t think this was a sob story like some people I think it’s truly a gift.

Anonymous said...

I think he was in Afghanistan. He was very talented.

Cody Barlow

Anonymous said...

Zach Cahalan
I don't know it's hard to tell. It's kinda weird how he does not stutter at all while singing. I think his singing was good but not America's best talent.

Dr. Watson said...

I’m not going to make my decision based off of what little information I know. I don’t think his singing wasn't good enough. Really I don’t care much about America’s got Talent.

Mary Alice said...

I'm not sure that I believe it. It seems like he was stuttering on purpose because he didn't really stutter when he talked the second time. I think that he is doing it for the attention and just to be on the show. I'm not sure that he is even good enough to move on.

Anonymous said...

Yes I believe the story he said. When he talks he studder because of the grenade they don't studder in a rhythm. Yes because he was playing a guitar and singing.
-Travis Legate

Makayla said...

I believe that this man is telling the truth. I don't think that his stuttering has anything to do with his singing ability. I think that he deserves to move on to the next level of America's Got Talent because he has an amazing voice.

Anonymous said...

It is hard to tell whether he is faking it or not. It's strange how he didn't get a purple heart though. No one will know whether he is really faking it or not. He would be the only one to actually know. However, he does sing very well. -Josh Cutchins

Anonymous said...

There ain't no telling. HE seems like a nice guy. But it's always the ones you don't expect. he can sing pretty good though.

Chris Stepp

Jameela said...

This video is sad and to watch . But when I was told that he was lying that made me upset because I cried at first . His story was very sad and touching .

aaron said...

well its kinda funny how he studers when he talks but not when he sings. His singing was alright.

Amber Furman said...

I believe him because the pictures and I don't think someone would make that up but who knows. I think he deserves to move on to the next level. I thought he was a good singer. I don't think he should win, but he should go on for a little while for what talent he does have.

Charlene Turner said...

I really believe his story even though a lot of people would make up things like that. I think he does deserve to move on he can sing.